The EU Referendum

As you know, I don’t discuss politics here on my blog but I’m going to make an exception for the EU Referendum because, whichever way you look at it, it’s a big deal.

I have agonized about my decision.  There are lots of reasons why we should leave and similarly valid reasons why we should stay (there’s a basic guide to the EU and the referendum on the BBC’s website).  I’ve taken everything the politicians have said with a pinch of salt: they have their own agenda and self-serving interests, none of which have anything to do with your average Joe in the street.  They lie mercilessly.  In fact, the propaganda surrounding the referendum has sickened me.  I’ve always liked Barack Obama but when he waded in with veiled threats about not doing trade with the UK if we leave Europe I went right off him.  How would he feel if Europe told him we wouldn’t trade with America unless they unrestrainedly opened their borders to Mexico and accepted the hundreds of thousands of immigrants that would flood in?  Citizens they didn’t need or could afford in a time of huge austerity?  He’d tell us to bugger off and that America’s immigration policy was none of our damned business, and that’s exactly what I wanted to tell him to do.

It’s been almost impossible to find non-biased information and even my friends are very firmly in one camp or the other, constantly on Facebook spouting the latest propaganda and their reasons for staying or leaving.  Many of which may be valid, but are often based on information fed from the camp they are in allegiance with.

Here would be my reasons for leaving:

  • Britain entered the EU, formerly the Common Market, in 1975 with the sole purpose of helping trade between member countries, which then stood at 8. The reasoning behind the formation of the Common Market is that you are less likely to go to war with countries with which you trade.
    The EU now contains 27 countries (soon to be 28 with the addition of Turkey) and the European Parliament makes laws on everything from human rights to the environment, monetary policy to safety at work.  Britain, as a nation, did not agree to this.  We agreed to a committee of 8 neighbouring countries making combined decisions on trade, nothing else.
  • The UK, like all the other EU nations, elect MEPs (Members of the European Parliament), to vote at the European Parliament in Brussels.  However, the job of an MEP is to represent the interests of Europe not its own nation or people.  So, although they are elected by the British people they do not represent the British people in Parliament, instead deciding on laws which benefit Europe as a whole.
  • Because we belong to the EU we have to accept workers from the other 27 EU countries.  We have no control over these workers.  They don’t need to be skilled or even speak English.  We are a tiny island.  Germany is 5 times the size of the UK, yet has a population of 80 million against the UK’s population of 64 million.  In order for Germany to be as cramped as the UK it would have to swell its population by 240 million.  It has the space for 2 million immigrants.  We do not.
  • As of today, the UK has 1.67 million unemployed people.  We don’t have enough jobs for our own citizens, let alone people from other countries.
  • We have a massive housing shortage in the UK because of our ever growing population and lack of land. One of the reasons for the horrendous flooding we experience in the UK nowadays is that we keep having to build houses and build houses and build houses……….on grassy fields which used to soak up rainwater.  The more people who live here the more houses we will need to build on an ever decreasing land mass.  You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to know that given this scenario the flooding is going to get worse.  Much worse.
  • Our health service is literally cracking under the strain of our current population.  Our schools have to do charity fundraisers to buy computer and gym equipment.  Our Victorian sewerage and drainage system is crumbling.  Our roads are without a top layer of tarmac because we are, effectively, skint.  We can’t afford to house and sustain the citizens we already have, let alone a few million more.
  • We fought 2 wars, and lost millions of our people, to not be ruled by anyone.  Especially Germany.  Enough said.  Would American agree to abide by laws made by Vietnam or Japan?  I think not.

So, for me personally, the main reason to leave the EU would be so that we can control our borders.  I’m not talking about immigration here, or asylum.  I’m talking about the free flow of workers (who can then also claim our welfare benefits, eg. weekly child allowance for children who are still living in Poland and have never even been to the UK) through EU countries.

Here would be my reasons for staying:

  • We currently have a Government who, this week, is being hauled up in front of the United Nations for abusing its most vulnerable citizens.  We, the 5th richest economy on the planet, have taken austerity out on sick, disabled and disadvantaged people to such an extent that we are being accused of violating human rights.  It’s sickening.  My Government has done this despite being watched by the European Court of Human Rights and the UN.  Can you imagine what they’d do to their citizens if we left the EU and no-one was watching?
  • We may have to abide by laws made by the European Parliament but this may be no bad thing.  My Government has tried for decades to abolish rights for blue collar workers, rights our ancestors died for, and without our membership of the EU would have succeeded.
  • Our seas and rivers were filled with raw sewage and our countryside decimated by environmentally disastrous farming practices until we joined the EU.  Membership of the EU has been hugely beneficial to nature and our environment.
  • I live in the north of England, an area completely ignored by my Government and left to rot for decades.  The north has received millions of pounds from the EU for regeneration without which it would be a wasteland.
  • UK farmers receive large monetary subsidies off the EU, without which many would not survive.
  • Europe faces a terrorism threat.  We are safer being part of the EU, with its inter-agency and police co-operation and intelligence, than standing alone.

My main reason for staying in the EU would be the watchful eye Brussels keeps on my Government and its violation of human rights.

Notice I haven’t once mentioned the Economy.  That’s because no-one knows what would happen if we left the EU.  Leading up to the vote on whether or not Britain should ditch the £ and join the Euro currency there was dreadful scarmongering about what would happen to the UK’s economy if we didn’t adopt the Euro and guess what?  We didn’t adopt the Euro and absolutely bugger all happened – life just carried on as before.  In fact, as a nation we all breathed a sigh of relief following the crash when first Greece went bust, then Ireland went bust and Britain stayed one of the strongest economies in the world.  So I don’t listen to a word that’s said about falling stock markets or bankrupcy should Britain leave Europe because it’s all bollocks.

So, which way will I vote?  It’s been incredibly difficult to make up my mind.  We simply cannot cope with the free movement of workers in the EU and our Prime Minister tried very hard earlier on this year to reach an agreement with Brussels on limiting the influx of European workers to the UK and failed.  However, I worry more about my Government’s austerity measures which have impacted the sick and disabled to such an extent they are using food banks for survival, yet have left the richest 5% of the country better off.  So I will vote to stay, reluctantly and with huge reservations.  I don’t know if it’s the right choice or not, only time will tell.



4 thoughts on “The EU Referendum

  1. TC

    You’re not alone, Jak. I voted stay with my postal vote last week. I originally wanted ‘OUT’ but after a lot of reading and investigation, I have voted ‘IN’. There are more reasons to vote IN than OUT and to be honest if we are left with this bunch of Tory Toffs we will be in deep trouble. They don’t care a hoot about the NHS and the Welfare State or indeed the environment. Money and Greed are their masters. We are better in the EU for many reasons and we are safer in regards to wars, human and workers rights.
    You’ve decided well.


    1. Chris Walshe

      Absolutely right . Anything out of that appalling Ian Duncan Smith I simply will not buy . Imagine , he constructed that resignation scenario as a prelude to his campaign . What a travesty , given his career , to pose as a champion of the unfortunates who depend upon benefits.
      But deeply unhappily , the ” Give us our Country Back ” brigade have been fooled by their rhetoric . As witness this appalling murder , yesterday .

      Liked by 2 people

  2. Jill

    Hi, The EU. I could write a book on this but no-one needs anything that boring so I’ll try to keep it to topics raised. As an economist by being in a trading block helps to bring more wealth to our country as we are able to buy and sell in it automatically and not face tariffs excluded countries have to pay . Five years ago I was having many a major rant why the EU hadn’t decided to make a trade agreement with either India or China to increase our trade area/wealth as this next century belongs to their mass economies. Only the other day India and Japan signed a trade agreement to challenge China in the future. Here we are the UK, 5th largest economy, but only because we are IN the EU but nowhere near if we are out. This is what Obama was talking about. It wasn’t a slight on the UK he was simply talking about how international trade works. If the EU as a large block will buy eg 100 US cars and a UK on its own will buy 1, who do you trade with first?
    Many people forget that by being a member of the EU or EEC as was we are not separate entities. The UK voted who else to let into the EU. The MEP’s from the UK represent areas of the UK in the EU govt as MP’s in the UK represent areas of the UK in govt here. We talk of laws made in Europe as if they’ve been imposed on us yet the UK were in there voting for them. The Uk is a major law maker in the EU, 56 proposals went against us but over 2100+ went for us. As for Turkey, there isn’t a chance of Turkey being in the EU for another 30 years most likely 50 if not longer. It can’t meet many of the criteria the EU insist on especially regarding human rights. The EU has been playing nicely with Turkey simply because we want to use the Incirlik airbase for events in Syria and the Middle East.
    As for the economy, the pound has already fallen in value and will continue to do so until we have the referendum. If we leave are we prepared to be poorer through lack of trade? There will be major job losses as the EU market open to us now will not be, at the same prices, then. The poorer areas in the UK devastated by Maggie will no longer receive the cash directly sent to them to start up enterprise zones. Sent direct as the Tory UK govt gives nothing. Our whole economy is made up of Finance. Agriculture is only 3%, other industry even less. How many companies are foreign owned? The City of London finance is the only industry that keeps this country up and running. Staying out of the Euro was never a problem however the European Central Bank on Frankfurt would start running a lot, not all, of what London currently does. It’s easier for world business to go straight to the huge trade block centre. So the UK economy will slump in a major way.
    Immigration: The mixed up big question that Tory tabloids love. Yes compared to Germany, France and Spain the UK does have a smaller land area. However, we are not country number 1 that migrants want to come to despite what tabloids tell the masses. We’re about number 6. I fully support refugees (many of whom will return home once the problems in their countries are peaceful again) economic migrants however can turn round and go home and apply through the proper channels……..unless they offer skills in which this country has a shortage of. I mean look at all the qualified Spanish doctors that have come/are coming over as their economy goes to pot and the UK govt wants to increase the NHS to full 7 days a week cover. Should we refuse them? Migrants who pay taxes especially should stay (the govt coffers have made a profit out of them so far!). I hate the ‘they’re taking our jobs’ crap. Who’s employing them? Brits. Working for less money? You mean Brit employers are paying workers illegally below the minimum wage? Who is at fault if that’s so? The Brit employer!! Where would the NHS be and care homes without migrant workers?? If we did leave, would they all have to leave? Half of migrants don’t even come from the EU so leaving it is not an immediate save all. Nor would a leave vote be immediate, about 18 months they reckon.
    We all want the best for our country. It’s a shame that independent facts were not given to the UK people to make up their own minds and all politicians banned from speaking. I’m very tired now so will finish but could cover much more as I’m sure I’ve missed plenty out. I’m quietly kakking myself if the vote goes the wrong way as I’m too ill to live on less than the pittance we all receive now and having to then cope with all the prices going up. Just keeping my fingers crossed.



Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s